Go to main content
GoldenHeartsCas
GoldenHeartsCas › Sports Coverage › Jacob Misiorowski Is Pitching Like No One Ever Has
Article

Jacob Misiorowski Is Pitching Like No One Ever Has

· Sports Coverage

Jacob Misiorowski is in the middle of one of the most dominant pitching seasons the sport has ever seen. The question now is what it will take for that season to be remembered alongside the all-time greats.

In a recent ranking of the greatest single-season pitching performances, Misiorowski earned only a quick mention in the introduction as a pitcher on pace for an all-time year before the discussion turned to 2018 Jacob deGrom and 1985 Dwight Gooden. But the blueprint for greatness is there. If we understand what made the best pitching seasons so special, we can see what would push Misiorowski into that company.

pitcher mid-delivery on mound under stadium lights

The Two Pillars of a Historic Season

Two factors consistently shaped that ranking of the best pitching seasons. The first was dominance relative to other pitchers of the same era, the reason steroid-era Pedro Martinez in 1999 and 2000 stands as the greatest pitcher ever. The second was statistical outliers sustained over a full season.

Misiorowski needs a true mathematical trump card, something visible and obvious to everyone for the rest of time. Right now, that card is his ERA of 1.45, the best ever except for 1968 Bob Gibson and his patently absurd 1.12 ERA across more than 300 innings. That figure needs context: the strike zone was much larger in 1968 than it is today, and Gibson's dominance, along with that of Sandy Koufax and Don Drysdale, led to rule changes that corrected it. For all practical purposes, Misiorowski would pass 1985 Dwight Gooden for the best ERA ever outside that expanded zone.

A quick note on the word "ever": in this discussion it generally means since 1945, a sensible starting point for pitching legacy conversations. Many players returned from military service around then, integration began soon after, and pitchers stopped working enormous inning totals every year. The sport simply was not the same for pitchers before that point.

Beyond ERA: The Estimator Numbers

ERA is a flawed statistic, and it is not necessarily the best measure of true pitcher performance. ERA estimators like FIP and SIERA, which sit on the same scale as ERA and try to correct for things pitchers cannot control such as defense and balls in play, tell a fuller story.

SIERA data only goes back to 2002, but Misiorowski would rank third all-time in that club behind 2014 Clayton Kershaw and 2002 Curt Schilling, the latter by just .01. As for FIP, which measures how well pitchers prevent runs on their own rather than with defensive help, Misiorowski is on hallowed ground. Since 1945, he trails only 2021 Corbin Burnes and 1999 Pedro Martinez, the undisputed king of pitching seasons.

FIP may sound obscure, but it is a powerful tool. Misiorowski being elite in both FIP and ERA helps with other historical markers, namely Wins Above Replacement, which two websites calculate differently. Baseball-Reference's bWAR leans more on runs allowed, while FanGraphs' fWAR is FIP-based. Misiorowski rates as insane in both, meaning that if he keeps this up, his WAR total could go down as an all-timer. He is already on pace for about 10 WAR, a bonkers achievement for a starting pitcher in the age of the reliever.

Velocity That Defies Belief

Misiorowski's greatness goes beyond the numbers. He is also super cool because he throws super hard and refuses to throw slower.

MLB has moved away from a lot of fastballs and toward fewer but better ones. Misiorowski showed up and essentially said no, he would simply throw more, better fastballs.

radar gun reading triple digits at a ballpark

And why not? Using Baseball Savant's swing timing and miss distance data, 2026 Misiorowski's fastball ranks among the most unhittable pitches since tracking began in 2023. It may be the single least hittable pitch of them all, a fastball producing a 44 percent whiff rate. That is not something a pitcher is supposed to be able to do, and his fastball is the best swing-and-miss fastball in the majors since at least 2023, probably longer, among both starters and relievers.

The Ghost of 2021 deGrom

Even if the numbers do not fully convey how impossibly impossible this run is, there is historical intrigue to consider. Misiorowski is on pace for one of the greatest seasons ever, but he is not the most on pace anyone has ever been.

That title belongs to 2021 Jacob deGrom, who through basically the same number of innings was a wildly superior version of 2026 Misiorowski. DeGrom had a 1.08 ERA, a 1.24 FIP and 14.28 strikeouts per nine innings, all of which would have been the best ever. Then he got injured and missed the rest of the season, meaning he pitched by far the greatest half-season ever. Avoiding that fate is what Misiorowski needs most.

He throws hard, and while it is commonly debated whether velocity is the real culprit for UCL injuries and tears, it is obviously a concern that Misiorowski may not be able to sustain an output that makes him look like the Winter Soldier with a vibranium arm. But this is not about speculating on injuries. It is about whether this level is sustainable for the rest of the season.

Looking at expected statistics, Misiorowski is overperforming based on his contact quality, but so is every pitcher who has ever had a great season. He is not overperforming by that much, either. Most of his expected numbers sit within small enough margins that they deserve little concern, and the discrepancy mostly exists because it is not supposed to be possible to generate this kind of swing-and-miss with a fastball as a starter. It is legitimately unprecedented stuff.

Maybe that will regress, and maybe Misiorowski will start getting barreled later in the year. But there is a world where we look back on 2026 Misiorowski as one of the greatest pitching seasons in baseball history.

Perhaps the numbers will come back toward earth, and perhaps hitters will find a way to square him up in the months ahead. Even so, the season he is building is the kind that gets remembered for decades. The best advice is simple: drink it in while it lasts.

empty pitcher's mound at dusk in a large stadium

Related Stories